Monday, July 28, 2008

Control Our Borders (Sensibly)

I think this story demonstrates just how confused and pathetic our immigration policies have become. Far from becoming a free-for-all, the reality is that our immigration policy for citizens outside the EU is far too harsh in some misguided attempt to compensate for the fact that we cannot control how many people come to this country from the rest of the EU and in particular the new Eastern European member states. We are in desperate need of an immigration policy which not only controls the number of people who enter the country as many people wish, but is also sensible and sensitive to the needs of non-citizens who have a good reason to be here.

Thursday, July 24, 2008

Birmingham Media

The Stirrer is reporting that Equity is launching a campaign to save the BBC Drama Village in Birmingham as another decision to move the programmes to Salford has been put off. Most of my criticisms of the BBC are not the usual nonsense one will find in the blogosphere that it is biased to the left and the Labour party, but that it fails to represent all of the country in its programming and opinions, a position which is hard to justify because we all pay the same license fee. While I welcomed the move by the BBC to create a new major centre away from London in Greater Manchester, I do not think it is fair that programmes made in smaller BBC centres such as Birmingham and Bristol are being moved to justify its cost; the programmes should be moved from London and more smaller regional centres built. The way things are going, there will be very few BBC programmes produced outside London, Salford and Cardiff. This is hardly representative broadcasting.

Another thing about the BBC is the way it has bought into Brand Manchester, and often refers to its proposed Salford facility as "Manchester" rather than referring to the City of Salford in which it is actually located. On Radio Five Live the other day, they even asked whether the newly promoted Salford City Reds would be changing their name to Manchester! I am confused as to why the BBC want to promote geographical counties rather than proper cities; perhaps many of them are still confused by living in London.

The BBC's proposed flight from Birmingham is not the only one, however. Adrian Goldberg has consistently reported on his Stirrer website how local radio stations are shunning locally produced programmes to broadcast networked shows from London (even BBC WM moved a late night show from the city to Nottingham; Radio 2's late shows which were produced in the Mailbox have moved to London, as has the One Show despite the fact it was successfully piloted in Brum). Birmingham has always been very bad at promoting itself outside the region and the moves over the past few months seem to confirm that the city is seen as a broadcasting backwater.

It is not all bad news however. The steady stream of blows to Birmingham's media has led the creative community to look at the creation of a new radio station in Birmingham, Rhubarb Radio, which is probably going to be loosely based on Resonance FM in London and is hoping to start broadcasting soon from the Custard Factory. And Channel 4 will be opening its new digital media HQ in Birmingham. It seems that while the traditional media may be shunning Birmingham, new media looks set to embrace it. Whether this is the way forward remains to be seen.

Monday, July 14, 2008

TB or GB?

Mike Smithson wrote an article today at politicalbetting.com today asking the question whether Labour would be doing so badly in the polls if Tony Blair was still leader.

I think it is an interesting question. Personally, I fail to see how they could be any worse, but I struggle to square this with the fact that I much prefer Gordon Brown's inept leadership to Tony Blair's arrogant premiership. In my opinion, Brown's ratings have plummeted not because of the General Election that never was, but because of the 10p tax-rate debacle which goes against everything the Labour party stands for - a policy he more than anyone else was responsible for.

Along with the Iraq war (amongst the liberal wing of the party), and the failure to deal properly with the question of immigration (amongst sections of the white working classes), the 10p tax rate has led to many of those who lean Labour to look elsewhere instead. I remain to be convinced that there is a clamour for a Conservative government, and I would not rule out a 1992-style surprise where the electorate hold their noses and vote for Labour because there is no real will for a Tory administration, although I suspect this may just be wishful thinking. However, unless something changes soon, it is likely that Britain will be heading for a re-run of 1997 in reverse where the Government collapses at the polls leading to at least two terms of a Conservative government. Like 1997, the spread markets are not convinced - but there is a killing to be made if one believes the polls.

Sunday, July 06, 2008

Jewish Schools

A judge ruled this week that JFS, a Jewish school in London, was not guilty of racial discrimination when it refused to admit a Jewish boy because his mother was not born a Jew (she was a born a Catholic but converted before he was born). The judge claimed that the kind of admissions policy in question was "not materially different from that which gives preference in admission to a Muslim school to those who were born Muslim, or preference in admission to a Catholic school to those who have been baptised."

I think this is questionable. There is nothing in Islam or Catholicism (or indeed many strands of Judaism) that requires the mother, father or child to be "born" into that religion on some kind of ethnic basis. After conversion, or reversion, whatever that person used to be is irrelevant and they become a fully paid up member of the religion who in theory at least cannot be discriminated against. I tend to agree with the parent position that the school admission code contained a test "not based on faith but wholly or partly on ethnic origins" - something which is surely against race discrimination legislation?

Of course, it may not be that simple. Unlike Islam and Christianity, which seek to convert all of humanity to their cause, Judaism tends to be a religion one is born into rather than converted to, and has a history based around the ethnicity and traditions of a people. If we considered the refusal to admit a person with a non-Jewish mother as unlawful racial discrimination, we would be attacking the Orthodox version of the religion itself.

My experience of Jewish schools is shaped mainly from the excellent nearby King David Primary School in Birmingham, on which Jeremy Jacobs has written an excellent article on here. My mum always used to tell me that they did not admit Catholics into this school, not for any religious reasons but simply because there were so many Catholic schools in Birmingham to serve the Catholic community, but they welcomed applications from other religions and not least Muslims who were more than happy to apply in the absence of any Islamic schools which only became available relatively recently. I remember going to this King David's on a visit from my Catholic primary in order to learn about Jewish traditions, although to be honest at that age we tended to be more interested in having running races with the pupils of that school during break time than learning the traditions of Passover. Boys will be boys.

The admissions policy of King David Primary probably put a seed in my mind that Jews and Muslims make natural allies, something I still tend to believe and promote today, a position which has become more entrenched as I learn more about the history of Europe and the Middle-East. While there is no doubt the issue of Israel has sullied relations between the two religions in recent years, and there have been periods of intolerance between the religions before then, I believe that these positions tend to be promoted by certain groups for short-term political gain, and are not an accurate reflection of the much more complicated relationship that has existed between the two religions.

Do people have any thoughts on this? Is King David the exception rather than the rule and do I have a warped understanding of the relationship between Islam and Judaism as a result. And is JFS discriminating racially by not allowing in children born to non-Jewish mothers even when they have converted. I would be interested to know what you think.

Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Hell On Wheels Premiere

You know when you have made it when you get invited to UK film premiere's... sort off. The following popped into my inbox with the words 'Please forward' so i thought I would give it some publicity.

Birmingham does not often host film Premieres of any kind (George Clooney's 'The Perfect Storm' opened in Star City, while Will Smith set a new record by attending three premieres in one day, including one on the UGC on Broad Street for his film 'Hitch') so supporting even smaller films like this is a worthy endeavour.







YOU ARE INVITED TO THE EUROPEAN PREMIERE OF:

Hell on Wheels

Fresh from Official Selection screenings at festivals across North America and Australasia (including the South by Southwest Film Festival and the San Francisco DocFest), Hell on Wheels is the ass-kicking documentary film telling the story of a group of Texas women who band together to resurrect roller derby for the 21st century. Emerging from the Austin music and arts scene, these women create a rock and roll fuelled version of all-girl roller derby that has spawned the derby craze that's sweeping the nation.

Now the UK ’s own Roller Derby league – the Birmingham Blitz Derby Dames – present the first European screening at Britain ’s oldest functioning cinema: The Electric Cinema, Birmingham , UK .

Premiere date: 5th July 2008

Screening times: 1pm and 11pm

Tickets: http://www.etickets.to/buy/?e=1324

online press kit and links to images and trailers at:

http://www.hellonwheelsthemovie.com/presskit.htm

2001: The birth of an all-girl roller derby revolution begins in Austin , Texas .

Starting a revolution ain't an easy affair. After overcoming countless hurdles to organize, recruit and train, the rowdy rollergirls known as Bad Girl, Good Woman (BGGW) enjoy a smashingly successful first year, only to find a rift forming among the ranks of the 80 women. Polarized by issues of insurance, finances, and the direction the league should take, disenchanted skaters pull together and collectively bring their grievances to management. Accusations fly, and emotions run high as the two camps face off.

Ultimately, 65 of 80 skaters walk and form their own player-run league. Dealt a near fatal blow, management doesn’t give up. Instead, they recruit and rebuild their league to rebound in dramatic fashion. What emerges from the near-disaster are the Lonestar Rollergirls and the Texas Rollergirls. Both leagues pioneer a modern era of roller derby and inspire thousands of women across the US to follow suit.

Shot over a four year period and utilizing both verite footage and interviews, Hell on Wheels documents the creation of modern-era roller derby’s first two leagues.

The success of the Texas leagues has inspired hundreds of women across the world. Leagues of rollergirls are currently organizing or operating in Los Angeles , New York City, Seattle , Phoenix , North Carolina , Houston , Nevada , Tucson , Kansas City, Dallas , Madison , New Jersey , Pennsylvania , Australia , England , New Zealand , Canada and beyond…

Sunday, June 29, 2008

Sie können die Deutschen nicht durchstreichen

Apologies for the lack of updates around here recently. It seems the Promroiship took quite a lot out of me, and combined with Euro 2008 and Twenty20 zonal games which have been taking up a lot of my time, blogging has been on a bit of a back-burner lately.

It was a great weekend of sport last week with Amir Khan fighting in Brum for the first time as a result of pressure from his fans. The fight was one of the most exciting I have ever seen, almost straight out of a Rocky movie, and I felt Khan displayed flashes of brilliance although it was evident that he still has a lot of work to do on his defence. The day before saw Warwickshire beat Worcestershire for the first time in the six years of the Twenty20 competition. The Bears were unbeaten until this Friday, when they lost to a half-decent Northamptonshire team. With the Twenty20 Champions League around the corner, I am just wondering whether the Bears are taking the competition seriously now. They have to be a decent bet to win it outright, but I have said that before.

The jammy Germans. As the BBC commentary-by-cliche team would say, you can never rule them out. Well you can, and I did; and now they are in the final. To be fair I suspected they might make an appearance on June 29th due to the fact they were in the easy half of the draw. Far from being a decent team that has undereachieved since winning Euro 1996 (as the Beeb would have it, although they soon changed their story after their defeat by Croatia), Germany have actually been a very weak team for the last 12 years, going out in the first round of the last two European Championships and going out in the quarter-finals of 1998 to an even better Croatian team than currently plies its trade. They were very lucky to get to the final in 2002, qualifying from a group including Ireland, Cameroon and Saudi Arabia (who they beat 8-0), and beating the might of Paraguay, USA and South Korea before losing 2-0 in the final to the only decent team they played - Brazil (to think we started in the Group of Death with Argentina, Sweden and Nigeria and met Brazil in the quarter final...grrr!). Two years ago, after some very low expectations from the home fans, they made the semi-final before crashing 2-0 to the Italians in extra-time; but competitions on home soil are the exception to the rule (which is the reason we have a World Cup to our name). This year, apart form a great performance against the Portuguese, they have again been pretty average. Despite all the pre-tournament hype, this is the same team that took over from the likes of Moller, Haessler, Sammer, Effenberg, Bierhoff, Kilinsmann and Voller, but had very little chance of emulating their success, except now they are a lot older and I see very little coming through to replace them. However, that is no excuse for them to be underdogs tonight, given that the Spanish have also had a relatively easy route to the draw, with the Russians in their two games not coming close to the performance of the tournament against the Dutch in the quarter-finals, and a win on penalties against an Italian team who are still recovering from their World Cup win two years ago. It would be great to see the Spanish win Euro 2008 (although it would hammer home just how poor England's record is amongst the big European nations, with only one major final in our history), but they have yet to display they have the mentality to do it. Something the Germans do not have a problem with.

One of those quirks of fate that satisfies me for reasons I simply cannot fathom; on the day the Germans played Poland in a competition held in Switzerland and Austria, Robert Kubica, a Pole, won the Canadian Grand Prix in a German car (BMW) which used to be Swiss-owned (Sauber). Apart from the fact that Austria and Canada spoil the symmetry of this, I am sure there is some hidden meaning in this. Or maybe a United double, a Blues relegation and a potential German victory in Euro 2008 after England failed to qualify have finally taken a mental toll.

Worst season ever.

(Headline courtesy of Babelfish)

Tuesday, June 03, 2008

A Gem of a Free Attraction

Apparently, the Museum of the Jewellery quarter in Birmingham has been ranked third in a list of the best free attractions in Europe. In an interesting article on the city recently by Iain Dale(in that it gave an outsiders view of Birmingham), one of the commenters noted that he tried to persuade his friend to buy and engagement ring from the area rather than Hatton Garden but she just would not listen.

Having lived in Birmingham all my life, I have known of the Jewellery quarter and its place in the history of the city, but have never really thought of it as one of our premier attractions. Perhaps we should pay more attention to this little gem of a local attraction.

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

The Promroiship 07/08: A Review

Manchester United completed another treble this season, winning the Premier League, the Champions League and the inaugural Promroiship. Alex Ferguson shows no signs of retiring; I think he might be after another Promroiship title.

The point of the Promroiship was, of course, to try and decide whether there was any detectable bias in the Match of the Day Running Order. So back in January I started the Promroiship (the PRObrum Motd (match of the day) Running Order Index with a -ship on the end) which ran with the following rules:

All teams appearing on Match of the Day will be awarded points based on the position of their game in the running order, the number of goals scored and the number of matches appearing on MOTD that weekend. Only Premiership games will count and MOTD2 is not included. Midweek MOTD will also count towards the total. The rules are as follows:

1) Teams appearing in the first match will be awarded 10 points, the next 9 and so on all the way down to 1 if necessary. As there are 20 teams in the premiership, a maximum of 10 matches can be played on any day involving all teams once.

2) Because matches with more goals should in theory come first, 1 point will be taken away for each goal scored in the match. I deliberated a lot about this rule, because a few high scoring matches before Christmas made this potentially unfair, but I think it is the easiest way to factor in "entertainment" at an objective level. In any case, it would not be football if their was not potential for an argument over the fairness of some rule or other.

3) Thanks to security considerations, Sky and European involvement, sometimes there can be very few matches on Saturday and so we need to factor in the number of matches shown. I have decided to multiply the result of the first two rules by the number of matches appearing on MOTD. Obviously the fact that some teams do not play on Saturday adds in some additional unfairness, but I hope that over half a season there will not be too much bias, and we should pick it up week by week if there is.
We ended up with the league table here which was very similar to the Premier League final table, in that Manchester United won and Derby were bottom.

As the season progressed, however, those who were following the competition would have noticed that Blackburn and Aston Villa seemed to play fewer matches on Saturday, which put them at a disadvantage, as foreseen by the third point above. So, for the purposes of analysis, I produced the following League Table based on average Promroiship points per appearance on MOTD - in other words, I divided the total number of Promroiship points by the number of appearances on Match of the Day each team had over the same period. This gave the following revised league table:

The Average Promroiship Points per Appearance 078


Team.................
Average...Apps..Prom Points
Manchester United ...48.08......13......625
Chelsea .............47.50......10......475
Bolton Wanderers ....41.42......12......497
Everton .............37.38.......8......299
Fulham ..............36.81......16......589
Arsenal .............36.08......13......469
Reading .............34.94......17......594
Portsmouth ..........33.17......12......398
Liverpool ...........32.70......10......327
Birmingham City......32.27......15......484
Wigan Athletic ......30.69......13......399
Tottenham Hotspur....30.29......14......424
Newcastle United.....29.75......12......357
Sunderland ..........28.00......14......392
West Ham United......26.20......15......393
Manchester City .....25.91......11......285
Aston Villa .........25.08......12......301
Blackburn Rovers.....23.58......12......283
Middlesbrough .......21.43......14......300
Derby County.........18.50......14......259

This has a much more familiar feel than the old Promroiship table, with Manchester United and Chelsea convincingly taking the top two spots, disproving my assertion in the last article that:

The Beeb may be biased towards Manchester United. The other Premier League contenders finished lower than those involved in the relegation battle.

Those in the relegation battle finished lower using averages than total Promoiship points, indicating that they played more games on Saturday (we could say Sky is biased against covering relegation battles, but I believe the Sunday games are decided well in advance). Everton are the big movers, finishing in the top four rather than the bottom four. City rivals Liverpool also move up a bit, having only played in ten out of nineteen possible MOTD apearances (well maybe less, since for example Villa and Blackburn brought one of their games forward creating a "phantom" round).

The second part of the comment, namely that the Beeb were biased against Derby, still seems valid however.

I realise that most people prefer visual representations rather than raw figures. So I started producing some graphs. The most obvious assertion is that the Match of the Day Running Order is decided by promotion and relegation battles. Let's plot the average Promroiship points against the teams in order of Premier League finishing position, starting with the Champions and finishing with the wooden spoon (click on the graph to enlarge):

There are obvious spikes around the Premier League title rivals and the relegation battlers. Midddlesborough can feel slightly aggrieved, although winning 8-1 in a nothing game on the last day of the season did not help their Promroiship chances. Aston Villa and Blackburn seem to prove that the Beeb were not interested in the race for the UEFA cup, although Everton and Portsmouth strangely seemed not to be affected by this. Were the BBC overcompensating for Phil Neville's comment about Everton always being last on Match of the Day, a statement which helped kick this competition off?

I added in the trend line for effect, but it is probably skewed by Manchester United, Chelsea and Derby' Promroiship performances. The overall average Promroiship points per match is 31.99, so as a rule of thumb teams over the 30 point line in the graphs on this page got more than their fair share of coverage, based on goals scored in the games, and those underneath less.

To recap then, there seems to be some evidence for the theory that the Beeb basis its MOTD running order on title and relegation battles. Are they biased towards big clubs? The graph above shows that the Big Four do better than average (although Arsenal and Liverpool probably do less well than expected). What about other big clubs/ sleeping giants? Of course, deciding which clubs are big is a minefield, so I decided to use the size of the stadium as a proxy for size of the club and see if there were any trends.

The trend line seems to indicate there is very little correlation between size of a club's stadium and their average Promoiship points. Either our definition of big club is faulty (quite probably), or the Beeb believe that size does not matter. The fact that the spikes centre around the likes of Manchester United, Chelsea and the relegation battlers is probably more telling.

Finally, this would not be a Birmingham blog if I did not complain about London bias. Is MOTD biased towards the self-styled capital of the world? In the next graph I order the teams (broadly) in distance from Wembley stadium:

The trend line seems to pick something up, but again final Premier League positions seem to be more important when looking at the spikes. The North-East does seem to be discriminated against, but none of their three teams were probably ever serious relegation (or title) candidates.

In conclusion then, Match of the Day in the second half of the season concentrates on league positions rather than high scoring matches. Teams involved in relegation battles and title challenges are more likely to be featured before teams languishing in mid-table obscurity. As such, it would make more sense to run the Promroiship from the beginning of the season to December 31st than January 1st to the end. Such a season would be more likely to expose any potential MOTD bias, which, from this experiment, is hard to prove conclusively exists.

Another conclusion is that Phil Neville talks b*******s. Everton do not always appear last on Match of the Day, and are probably shown higher up the order than they should be when the number of goals in their matches are taken into account.

Match of the Day concentrates on title/ relegation battles. Phil Neville talks crap. Probably did not need to create the Promroiship to prove these two self-evident truths.

See you again (maybe) next season.

Monday, May 12, 2008

United Secure League Double

Manchester United completed a Premier League and Promroiship double yesterday after amassing a massive 80 points in their final game against Wigan which featured joint first on Match of the Day along with Chelsea and Bolton (both awarded 10 running order points). THis saw them win the inaugural Promroiship competition as the only team to secure more than 600 points. The relegation battles featured next (joint third - awarded 8 running order point each) which saw Fulham avoid relegation and finish third in the Promroiship, above west London rivals Chelsea but not above Reading unlike the Premier League. With every Premier League team featuring on Match of the Day yesterday, it was always likely that high scoring mid-table matches would generate negative points and Middlesborough's thrashing of Manchester City saw them lose 50 points each this week, dropping City into the bottom three. It was not enough to take Derby of the bottom though, who completed a miserable season finishing bottom of every league they entered (except the Gubbometer, which they won with weeks to spare). Blackburn finished second from bottom, despite being involved in the relegation battle; conceding four goals will not help you in any league (unless it involves counting the number of goals you have conceded).

I am hoping to make a more detailed analysis of the Promroiship and will probably post this over next weekend. Provisional conclusions are as follows:

1) The Beeb may be biased towards Manchester United. The other Premier League contenders finished lower than those involved in the relegation battle. Derby on the other hand, were almost always last (as the Gubbometer proved).

2) Match of the Day in the second half of the season concentrates on league positions rather than high scoring matches. Teams involved in relegation battles and title challenges are more likely to be featured before teams languishing in mid-table obscurity.

3) As such, it would make more sense to run the Promroiship from the beginning of the season to December 31st than January 1st to the end. Such a season would be more likely to expose MOTD bias, which, from this experiment, is hard to prove conclusively exists.

Just to remind you, weekly points are calculated using the formula (m-g)*n where

m is the points for position in the running order (10 for appearing in first match, 9 for second etc)
g is the number of goals in match
n is the number of Premier League matches on MOTD

Promroiship Results May 3rd 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Joint First
Wigan Athletic v Manchester United..80

Chelsea v Bolton Wanderers..........80

Joint Third
Portsmouth v Fulham.................70
Birmingham City v Blackburn Rovers..30
Derby County v Reading..............40

Normal Order
Everton v Newcastle United..........10
Middlesborough v Manchester City...-50
West Ham United v Aston Villa......-10
Totenham Hotspur v Liverpool........0
Sunderland v Arsenal................0

The Promroiship Table after Round 18

Manchester United ...625
Reading .............594
Fulham ..............589
Bolton Wanderers ....497
Birmingham City......484
Chelsea .............475
Arsenal .............469
Tottenham Hotspur....424
Wigan Athletic ......399
Portsmouth ..........398
West Ham United......393
Sunderland ..........392
Newcastle United.....357
Liverpool ...........327
Aston Villa .........301
Middlesbrough .......300
Everton .............299
Manchester City .....285
Blackburn Rovers.....283
Derby County.........259

* indicates match played in Round 18

Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Reading Stun United to go Top

Unbelievable. Just as it looked like Manchester United had wrapped up the Promroiship, Reading nick a one goal defeat to go top with a week to go. The Red Devils, clearly distracted by the Premier League title, succumbed to a disastrous 5 goal win which meant that despite heading the Match of the Day Running Order they obtained less Promroiship points than the third match involving the Royals. With Fulham also closing the gap we are in for an exciting final Promroiship weekend, with a full slate of Premier League fixtures giving us a multiplier in the formula below of 10 - the maximum possible and unprecedented since the competitions inception.

A bottom of the table clash between Blackburn and Derby saw both teams keep up their weak Promroiship form and achieve no points, leaving things at the bottom exactly the same as they were as last week. There is little point having a high scoring match at this time in the season when you are playing for very little.

Just to remind you, weekly points are calculated using the formula (m-g)*n where

m is the points for position in the running order (10 for appearing in first match, 9 for second etc)
g is the number of goals in match
n is the number of Premier League matches on MOTD

Promroiship Results May 3rd 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Manchester United v West Ham....35
Fulham v Birmingham City........49
Reading v Tottenham Hotspur.....49
Bolton Wanderers v Sunderland...35
Middlesborough v Portsmouth.....28
Aston Villa v Wigan Athletic....21
Blackburn Rovers v Derby County..0

The Promroiship Table after Round 18


Reading .............554*
Manchester United ...545*
Fulham ..............519*
Arsenal .............469
Birmingham City......454*
Tottenham Hotspur....424*
Bolton Wanderers ....417*
West Ham United......403*
Chelsea .............395
Sunderland ..........392*
Middlesbrough .......350*
Newcastle United.....347
Manchester City .....335
Portsmouth ..........328*
Liverpool ...........327
Wigan Athletic ......319*
Aston Villa .........311*
Everton .............289
Blackburn Rovers.....253*
Derby County.........219*

* indicates match played in Round 18

Saturday, May 03, 2008

I've Got a Lovely Bunch of Cocunuts

Bruce Forsyth presented 'Have I Got News for You' and resurrected his career hosting 'Strictly Come Dancing'.

Boris Johnson presented 'Have I Got News for You' and became the new Mayor of London.

Next weeks guest presenter: Barack Obama

So Boris is the new Mayor of London. My position on the matter is no different from what it was back in September. The Mayor of London should be a training ground for a future Prime Minister, not a popularity contest. It is unlikely that Boris will ever reach 10 Downing Street however well he runs London. Having said that, perhaps the left have underestimated Boris by assuming he is a bit of a clown who appears on comedy game shows. The reality is he ran a very good campaign to unseat Ken Livingstone, a feat which should not be underestimated itself despite the rantings of the right-wing press. It will be interesting to see how he performs in his new role.

If the Mayor has not undermined 'World-class' London, the BNP getting a seat on the GLA certainly has. As this article points out, Berlin, Paris and New York do not suffer from this embarrassing situation. I hope the London media remember this the next time they report on racial tensions in Birmingham, Bradford or any other northern towns they want to disparage.
At least we have not elected a fascist to the largest council in Europe.

Sunday, April 27, 2008

United Close in on (a) Title

The problem with top of the table deciders is that, in Promroiship terms, they always end up in draws. Luckily, however, in the Promroiship, Chelsea have fallen well behind Manchester United over the weeks as the BBC (and everyone else) regarded Arsenal as the title challengers. Yesterdays big match ended up with Manchester United returning to the top of the Promroiship and looking likely to win the inaugural Promroiship title.

Reading, however, are putting up a great challenge, only conceding seven points to Manchester United after their nil-nil bore draw with Wigan featured fifth on Match of the Day, but ended getting the second highest Promroiship score of the day. With the running order being decided more by the effect on the important parts of the Premier League table rather than the quality of the matches (or number of goals scored), we saw some high scoring matches being left very late on with the last two not actually scoring any points in the Promroiship; they might as well have stayed at home. Even Gary Lineker remarked upon this as he presented the last match, a meaningless mid-table fixture between West Ham and Newcastle. Given this, the running order yesterday probably could not be faulted unless you live in the North East and had to wait until the penultimate match to see an exciting local derby between Sunderland and Middlesborough.

Just to remind you, weekly points are calculated using the formula (m-g)*n where

m is the points for position in the running order (10 for appearing in first match, 9 for second etc)
g is the number of goals in match
n is the number of Premier League matches on MOTD

Promroiship Results April 26th 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Chelsea v Manchester United...49
Manchester City v Fulham......28
Birmingham City v Liverpool...28
Tottenham Hotspur v Bolton....35
Wigan Athletic v Reading......42
Sunderland v Middlesborough....0
West Ham v Newcastle United....0

The Promroiship Table after Round 17

Manchester United ...510*
Reading .............505*
Arsenal .............469
Fulham ..............470*
Birmingham City......405*
Chelsea .............395*
Bolton Wanderers ....382*
Tottenham Hotspur....375*
West Ham United......368*
Sunderland ..........357*
Newcastle United.....347*
Manchester City .....335*
Liverpool ...........327*
Middlesbrough .......322*
Portsmouth ..........300
Wigan Athletic ......298*
Aston Villa .........290
Everton .............289
Blackburn Rovers.....253
Derby County.........219

* indicates match played in Round 17

Saturday, April 26, 2008

Can't Stop! Hemming Time!




According to the Stirrer, John Hemming has released a new single highlighting injustice in the family courts ("Help the Children?"). His music career has known better days, however, having been a huge superstar in the early 90's. I have a copy of one of his earlier albums.

Well, I've never seen them in the same room.

Picture courtesy of John Hemming.


Thursday, April 24, 2008

Candidate Apathy

We hear a lot about voter apathy, but what about when the candidates cannot even be bothered with democracy?

I went to the Balsall Heath Hustings last night, looking forward to listening to a debate between the candidates so I could decide who to vote for having recently moved to the area. When I got there, I was very disappointed to find that only two candidates had turned up, namely the Respect candidate and the Conservative candidate. Clearly the candidates for the Labour Party, the Lib Dems, the Greens, the BNP and the Independent Community Party had more important things to do. Apparently Mohammed Azim, the Labour party candidate has not been present at the hustings for the last three years!

This leaves me in a bit of a problem. I was not planning on voting for either of the parties who actually turned up. What should I do?

It looks like I have three options:

1)
Vote for one of the parties that turned up. At least they care, even if I do not agree with what they stand for

2) Give the candidates who did not turn up the benefit of the doubt and vote based on election literature, or relevant ward, local and/ or national issues?

3) Follow the example of the majority of the candidates, reject my democratic rights and do something more important instead?


I am being serious when I say my vote is up for grabs, so please, whatever your party allegiance, use the comments below to inform me of what you think the important issues are at this election and who I should vote for. All comments will be considered seriously.

For context, the 2007 results were as follows:

Sparkbrook Ward, Birmingham City Council

Candidate Party Number of Votes
Shokat Ali Community Independent Party (UK)

503

Charles John Alldrick The Green Party

310

Mohammed Azim The Labour Party

2503

Arthur Charles Botterill British National Party

106

Anwar Hussain The Conservative Party

548

Mohammed Ishtiaq Respect

3514

Dilawar Khan Liberal Democrat

919

Candidate Elected - Mohammed Ishtiaq


A review of the husting is available here.

Monday, April 21, 2008

A River of Blood

Yesterday was the 40th anniversary of the infamous "Rivers of Blood" speech made by Enoch Powell in the Midland Hotel in Birmingham. I do not know what to make of Mr Powell, who was probably as far from a caricature of a knuckle-dragging racist as you could get, and was actually a very intelligent guy who had a great understanding of other cultures and could speak around 10 languages. I will mark the anniversary by having a go at his less spectacular self-appointed heir, former PPC for Halesowen and Rowley Regis, local Tory-nut Nigel Hastilow, who not so long ago came up with the original idea that Enoch Powell was right.

In his recent tribute to the speech in the Torygraph, he comes up with the following classic quote, the kind that has been appearing on his blog for the two years or more since I have been linking to it, well before he became famous for that article in the Express & Swastika:
There have been plenty of incidents, from the riots of the Eighties to the 7/7 London bombings, where blood has been shed and where, one way or another, immigration might be blamed. How much blood constitutes a river?

Well let's work it out Mr Hastilow. The Roe River disputedly holds the title of the shortest river in the world (along with the D river). Unfortunately, I cannot find any information on the volume of either, but the Spring that discharges water into the Roe River, on its way to the River Missouri, conservatively discharges around 150 million gallons of water a day.

The average human body contains around 10 pints of blood. I think that is British Imperial compared to the probable American Imperial figure quoted above. For the purposes of the calculation it is unimportant, as I am estimating and the difference is not that huge. There are 8 pints in every gallon, which leads me to conclude that 120 million human beings would have to die through acts related to immigrantion for a river of blood to flow for one day. That is twice the population of the United Kingdom.

Nigel Hastilow need not be to disheartend. We could have chosen a longer river with a smaller throughput. Or perhaps the river only needs to flow for a few seconds. Nonetheless, there would have to be a hell of a lot more immigration and killings related to it before we could describe the result as a "river of blood".

If my calculations above are correct, using this definition as a river, neither 7/7 (52 people) nor 9/11 (3000 people) nor the Iraq War (very conservatively 30,000) nor even the Jewish Holocaust (6 million) come close to becoming a river. You have to start thinking in terms of the Bubonic Plague (75 to 200 million) or the two World Wars combined (20 million in the first, 70 million in the second, a total of 90 million according to Wikipedia; a more consevative 70 million total on this website) to get close. Many right-wingers claim that Communism is responsible for the deaths of 100 million people, while some estimates (particularly by black historians) of deaths caused by the global slave trade in Africans come up with a figure of around 50 - 100 million as a conservative figure (eg see the Black Holocaust for Beginners), although classical counts are around 10-20 million.

Was there a point to this macabre post? I was trying to show that emotive language adds nothing to the real issues caused by immigration. Enoch Powell never used the term "Rivers of Blood" (although arguably he said much worse). That task was left to his modern day wannabes, whose sensationalist drivel makes more noise that real evidence ever could.

Sunday, April 20, 2008

A Tight Finish

(sigh) It looked like being such a good season. After yesterdays matches, however, it now looks as if the Blues will be relegated and the SCUM may end up with the double.

Or a treble. Manchester United closed the gap at the top of the Promroiship after being first on Match of the Day despite taking part in the late kick-off which usually runs later in the show. The BBC clearly believed the draw against Blackburn was more important than the twists and turns taking place in the relegation battle. The Promroiship now looks set for an exciting finish, with only 8 points separating the top three teams. Despite being third, I rate Manchester United favourites now that Arsenal's Premier League title hopes are over, unless Reading can create an upset by being involved in some low scoring relegation battles in the last few games. It may well depend upon how quickly the Premier League title is decided.

Promroiship Results April 19th 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Blackburn v Man United...48
Middlesborough v Bolton..48
Fulham v Liverpool.......36
Arsenal v Reading........30
Wign v Tottenham.........24
West Ham v Derby.........12

The Promroiship Table after Round 16

Arsenal .............469*
Reading .............463*
Manchester United ...461*
Fulham ..............442*
Birmingham City......377
West Ham United......368*
Sunderland ..........357
Newcastle United.....347
Bolton Wanderers ....347*
Chelsea .............346
Tottenham Hotspur....340*
Middlesbrough .......322*
Manchester City .....307
Portsmouth ..........300
Liverpool ...........299*
Aston Villa .........290
Everton .............289
Wigan Athletic ......256*
Blackburn Rovers.....253*
Derby County.........219*

* indicates match played in Round 16

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Boycott London 2012

As the Olympic torch arrives in India, home of a largest exiled Tibetan community, on its round the world tour, there have been more demonstrations against China's occupation of Tibet following the ones in Europe and America last week. I think it is great that what was intended to be a propaganda coup by the Chinese government has ended up as being a great advert for the Free Tibet campaign. The truth is Beijing should never have got the Olympics, although it has to be said that part of the reason the IOC did award the Olympics to Beijing was because the government claimed improved human rights was going to be one of the legacies.

However, awarding 2008 to Beijing was not the last mistake the IOC made. They dropped an even bigger clanger by awarding 2012 games to London. Hopefully the run-up to two weeks of national embarrassment will be preceded by round the world demonstrations against the awarding of the games to this "world-class city". Here are some of the things one could protest about:

Operation Iraqi Liberation (do not worry, in four years we will still be there)
Free Afghanistan
Free the Chagos Islands
Libere Las Malvinas
Free Scotland
Unite Ireland
Free Wales
Free Cornwall
Free Birmingham

Or even better, perhaps the United Kingdom of Greater London could make the M25 into a moat and declare independence. Then we could all sod off. I am struggling to think of a catchy slogan for this cause however.

Any ideas?

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Derby Hit for Six

With the big four not playing, it was a chance for those involved in the Premier League's relegation battle to get some much needed exposure on MOTD, with Reading taking full advantage and moving up to second in the Promroiship, overtaking Manchester United, whose recent fixation with Sunday fixtures seems to have derailed their Promroiship hopes.

There could not be much argument with the running order on MOTD last night. The first match featured two clubs invovled in the relegation battle, the next the other team in the relegation zone and then the fourth-from-bottom club against one chasing fourth place. Derby escaped being last by being thumped six-nil by Aston Villa, a high-scoring match which heightened their chances of finishing last in the Promroiship; despite their main rivals Blackburn not playing, they only picked up seven points as a result, lifting them above Blackburn by only two points, a margin they should have increased by much more.

The programme continued with the Sunderland match, a team who are not completely safe, and then two mid-table obscurity matches, ending with a goalless draw at Porstmouth. Pompey may already be in the cup final, but if they do not ruthlessly chase 5th place in the Premier League they could end up with a very disappointing Promroiship position.

A reminder, points are calculated using the following formula:

(Points for position in running order - number of goals in match) * number of Premier League matches on MOTD

where a team gets 10 points for featuring in the first Premier League match, 9 for the second etc.


Promroiship Results April 12th 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Reading v Fulham...........56
Bolton v West Ham..........56
Birmingham v Everton.......42
Derby v Aston Villa........7
Sunderland v Man City......21
Tottenham v Middlesbrough..21
Portsmouth v Newcastle.....28

The Promroiship Table after Round 15


Arsenal .............439
Reading .............433*
Manchester United ...413
Fulham ..............406*
Birmingham City......377*
Sunderland ..........357*
West Ham United......356*
Newcastle United.....347*
Chelsea .............346
Tottenham Hotspur....316*
Manchester City .....307*
Portsmouth ..........300*
Bolton Wanderers ....299*
Aston Villa .........290*
Everton .............289*
Middlesbrough .......274*
Liverpool ...........263
Wigan Athletic ......232
Derby County.........207*
Blackburn Rovers.....205


* indicates match played in Round 15

Saturday, April 12, 2008

Will Blackburn Finish Ninth?

As I pointed out in my last post, some computer problems prevented me from posting this earlier in the week, but it will take more than a dodgy processor to stop the People's Republic updating the world on Birmingham's greatest fictional league competition.

With Manchester United playing Middlesbrough on Sunday, Arsenal took full advantage of their Saturday fixture to take the top spot in week 14 of the Promroiship. The other two of the big four also featured in the first two matches on the Beeb's flagship footie programme, with the FA Cup semi-final separating them from the trash rest of the show. It got me thinking of how I should deal with the positioning of non-Premier League matches (and possibly evening kick-offs, which tend to feature later on the show) in the scoring system should I continue to run this next year. If anyone has any ideas please feel free to post them in the comments.

After the FA Cup break, the BBC decided to concentrate on the relegation battle, but decided that matches with one team involved the the battle (Bolton and Reading) were more important than the match between Wigan and Birmingham, where both teams were (before the match at least) in trouble at the wrong end of the table. With Derby not playing, Blackburn managed to get themselves off the bottom despite featuring in the last match, a mid-table obscurity battle with Tottenham. Will they finish ninth? The BBC apparently could not give two hoots.

Promroiship Results April 5th 2008 (Match of the Day Running Order)

Arsenal v Liverpool....56
Man City v Chelsea.....49
Fulham v Sunderland....28
Aston Villa v Bolton...21
Newcastle v Reading....21
Wigan v Birmingham.....21
Blackburn v Tottenham..14

The Promroiship Table after Round 14


Arsenal .............439*

Manchester United ...413
Reading .............377*
Fulham ..............350*
Chelsea .............346*
Sunderland ..........336*
Birmingham City......335*
Newcastle United.....319*
West Ham United......300
Tottenham Hotspur....295*
Manchester City .....286*
Aston Villa .........283*
Portsmouth ..........272
Liverpool ...........263*
Middlesbrough .......253
Everton .............247

Bolton Wanderers ....243*
Wigan Athletic ......232*
Blackburn Rovers.....205*
Derby County.........200

Monday, April 07, 2008

Downtime

Typical. Had a week off and planned some daily blogging on a variety of interesting topics when my computer decides it has had enough. Luckily, I had already bought a new one. Unfortunately, it runs on Windows Vista which is incompatible with my existing modem. After trying unsuccessfully to find a compatible modem at PC World, I have decided to upgrade to wireless which I can get free if I upgrade my current internet package (it is actually faster and cheaper than the package I am on!). Unfortunately, it will take ten to fourteen days to arrive, which means blogging will be very light for the next couple of weeks, probably limited to updating the Promroiship table. The weekend's results will appear over the next couple of days.